Many business owners assume that a probation period is a safety net. If someone isn’t working out, they think the law gives them a free pass to let that person go with little risk. The reality is different. Probation does not remove a person’s right to challenge a termination, and it certainly does not stop a poorly handled dismissal from turning into a costly, time-consuming problem.

I was reminded of this recently when a client came to us about a manager they had hired in a senior role. The person was still within their probationary period, but there were performance concerns, and to make things more complicated, the employee had made a couple of complaints during their short time with the business. The client wanted to move on from the relationship but was worried about the risk of litigation and damage to their reputation.

This is where the misunderstanding about probation really shows up.

Probation gives an employer a shorter notice period and a lower threshold to assess fit. It does not erase the need to undertake a robust and considered for a fair process. If an employee has made complaints, especially complaints that could be characterised as workplace rights or grievances, a termination that follows too closely can look like retaliation. Even if that is not the intent, perception matters. A tribunal or court does not ask what the employer intended. It asks what a reasonable person in the employee’s position might conclude.

The client in this situation had two problems. First, they needed to exit the manager as smoothly as possible. cleanly. Second, they needed to make sure the exit could not be linked to the complaints in a way that suggested victimisation. That meant we could not rely on the fact that the person was on probation and simply move to dismissal. We had to look at the timing, the reasons, the documentation, and the way the conversation would be handled.

A risky termination becomes risky when the process is rushed, the reasons are unclear, or the employee feels ambushed. In this case, we worked with the client to separate the performance issues from the complaints, to make sure the file showed a consistent pattern of concerns that existed before and independently of the complaints, and to structure the termination conversation so it was respectful, direct, and legally defensible.

One of the biggest mistakes I see is employers treating probation like a grace period where anything goes. They delay the hard conversations, hoping the person improves, then act suddenly when patience runs out. That gap between feedback and action creates risk. If there is no record of the issues being raised, no opportunity to respond, and no clear standard the person was expected to meet, a dismissal can look arbitrary. Arbitrary decisions invite scrutiny.

Another common trap is assuming that because the person has only been there a short time, they will not bother to challenge the termination. People do challenge terminations, particularly when they feel wronged, embarrassed, or financially exposed. Even if the final outcome favours the employer, the process of responding to a claim takes time, money, and emotional energy. It also affects team morale, and can lead to business reputational damage. Other employees watch how exits are handled, and they draw conclusions about how safe the culture is.

So what should a business owner do when a probationary employee is not working out, especially one who has made complaints?

Start by documenting early and honestly. If there are performance concerns, raise them as they arise. Keep notes. Give the person a genuine chance to improve or respond. If complaints have been made, handle them properly and separately. Do not let the existence of complaints pressure you into keeping someone who is genuinely not right for the role, but do not let the desire to exit them override the need for a fair process.

Before terminating, test your reasoning. Would the decision look reasonable to someone outside the business? Is the timing explainable? Are the reasons supported by evidence? Is the conversation going to be handled with dignity? If the answer to any of these is uncertain, pause and get advice.

Probation is a useful tool for assessing fit. It is not a shield against poor process. The businesses that handle these situations well are not the ones who know every legal technicality. They are the ones who act early, act fairly, and act with a clear record of why the decision was made.

If you are facing a tricky termination, especially one involving complaints or sensitive circumstances, the key is not to avoid the decision. It is to make the decision defensible.

Nick Hedges is the founder of Resolve HR, a Sydney-based HR consultancy specialising in providing workplace advice to managers and business owners. He recently published his first book, “Is Your Team Failing Or Kicking Goals – Take Control of Your People & Their Performance”. It is a practical response to the most pressing HR challenges, which can be found at https://resolvehr.com.au/.

Disclaimer: The contents written do not constitute legal advice and do not cater for individual circumstances.   The information contained herein is not intended to be a substitute for legal advice and should not be relied upon as such.

Add Comment